Integrative phylogenomics: positions SPONGE at the root of the animal tree

This is an interesting and unexpected story. GEITP came across this Nov 2025 article (“Integrative phylogenomics: positions SPONGE at the root of the animal tree”), which would counterbalance the 25 Apr 2026 email blog — claiming that the comb jelly, not the sponge, was the root of the animal tree-of-life. However, when we attempted to download the 6-page Research Article (Science 13 Nov 2025; 390: 751-756) and the 2-page editorial (Science 13 Nov 2025; 390: pp 673-674 editorial), the journal Science reported that this study has been retracted.

5 FEBRUARY 2026 Science

RETRACTION of Research Article “Integrative phylogenomics positions sponges at the root of the animal tree”:

On 13 Nov 2025, Science published the Research Article “Integrative phylogenomics positions sponges at the root of the animal tree” by Jacob L. Steenwyk and Nicole King (1). The authors alerted us that errors in the analysis pipeline had affected the results — to an extent that the data are no longer reliable.

Two aspects of the data analysis introduce artifacts. First, an imbalance between the number of sponges and ctenophores in the dataset biased one of the scoring metrics, thereby influencing the outcomes. Second, part of the analysis involved collapsing internal nodes, which was not properly accommodated by the software used. The authors thank Casey W. Dunn and colleagues (Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at Yale University), for bringing this to their attention, as detailed in an eLetter and in Steenwyk and King’s eLetter Response — both of which are available at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adw9456#elettersSection. Given these issues, both authors have requested a Retraction. Science is therefore retracting the Research Article.

–H. Holden Thorp, Editor-in-Chief, Science

REFERENCES AND NOTES

1. J. L. Steenwyk, N. King, Science 390, 751 (2025).

The first pdf attachment is the 2-page 13 Nov 2025 editorial, which is a valid summary (except it is based on the retracted article). The second pdf attachment includes the 5 Feb 2026 Retraction Note. ☹ At this point in time, GEITP continues to favor the “comb-jelly first” hypothesis… 😊

DwN

This entry was posted in Center for Environmental Genetics. Bookmark the permalink.